top of page

Choosing the Right Roofing Material for Replacing Your Roof

Are you considering a roof replacement? That's a big decision, but there is no need to worry. We will guide you through the choices and help you discover the perfect match for your home. Selecting the roofing material is like selecting the hat—it should look good, feel comfortable, and, above all, shield your head (or, in this case, your home) from all weather conditions.

Climate and Weather

Let's start by discussing the factors you should take into account. Your local climate and weather patterns are crucial in determining which roofing material will suit your needs best. If you reside in an area like Sarasota, Florida, materials that reflect heat and maintain a cool interior, like metal or tile, could be ideal.


Let's not overlook your budget. Roofing materials come with varying price tags, from options like asphalt shingles to premium choices such as metal or tile. It's essential to strike a balance between quality and cost when making your selection. But the more expensive materials often last longer and are more energy efficient, so they can actually help you save money in the long-term.


Another important factor to think about is the design of your home. You want your roof to match the appearance and vibe of your house, not clash with it. If you have a Mediterranean or Spanish style home, tile roofing is a timeless option that will never go out of fashion. For a stylish look, metal roofing can really make a statement. If you prefer a traditional feel, asphalt shingles come in various colors and styles to complement any home.


Let’s examine the specifics of each roofing material, starting with asphalt shingles. They are affordable, versatile, and work well with everything. They are also relatively easy to install, making them a good choice for DIY projects. The downside? Asphalt shingles have a shorter lifespan compared to some materials, usually lasting around 20–30 years (or less with some insurance companies). They are also not as energy efficient since they tend to retain heat.

If you're in the market for a longer-lasting roofing material, metal could be a choice. Metal roofs have a lifespan of 40–70 years or longer and boast impressive strength. They are efficient at reflecting heat, aiding in keeping your house cool, and cutting down on energy costs. Metal roofs come in styles offering the appearance of roofing materials along with the advantages of metal. 

The primary downside to metal roofing is its price; it tends to be more expensive than asphalt shingles. Additionally, it can produce some noise during stormy weather, which may be bothersome if you're sensitive to sound.

For a classic appearance, tile roofing is an option. Whether you opt for clay or concrete tiles, these roofs are designed to last over 50 years. They are resistant to fire and energy efficient, providing top notch insulation for your residence. 

Tile roofing does come with a price tag; it ranks among the pricier choices available. Tile roofs can also be quite heavy, necessitating that your home's structure can support the added weight. Addressing any broken tiles might also pose some challenges.

If you have a low sloped roof, you may be curious about your choices. Modified bitumen is a more common residential option with a dual layer system that can be  torch-applied, cold-applied, or self-adhered. Single-ply membranes such as TPO  (thermoplastic polyolefin) are a commercial product that is also used in residential settings due to their long term durability.

Decision Time

So how do you select the roofing material for your house?  In sunny regions like ours, choose materials with properties to maintain a cool indoor environment. 

You will also want to factor in your budget when deciding on roofing materials. Although choosing the least expensive option may be tempting, remember that your roof is a long term investment. Investing initially in an energy efficient material can lead to cost savings over time.

Remember to also think about the design of your house. Your roof should add to the look of your home, not take from it. Choose materials that go well with the style and colors of your house.

Additionally, think about what you have planned for the future of your home. If you're going to be in your home for many years, investing in durable materials like metal or tile could be a good idea. If you're considering selling, more affordable options, like asphalt shingles, might be a better fit.

New Wave Roofing is Here to Assist

Feeling unsure? Don't stress; it's completely normal. Selecting a material is a choice, but you don't have to figure it out by yourself. Consulting with an expert like us at New Wave Roofing can help you understand what will best suit your needs. We can evaluate your home and budget requirements to assist you in making an educated decision.

Ultimately, the best roofing material is one that meets all your criteria—it aligns with your budget, matches your home's aesthetics, and offers protection and resilience for your climate. Whether you opt for asphalt shingles, modern metal roofing, or timeless tile, investing in a high quality roof is a way to enhance your home.

Doing a little research and seeking advice from experts will help you discover the roofing material that suits your needs. Your home is your sanctuary, and your roof is its crowning glory, so make sure it's a crown that brings you joy!


bottom of page